Humayun Ahmed and the Patriarchy We Chose to Celebrate

Posted by

·

,

By Preetelata

Humayun Ahmed is one of those rare figures in Bangladesh whose popularity has become almost inseparable from our cultural identity. His books introduced generations to the pleasure of reading, his television dramas brought families together, and his characters became part of everyday conversations. Even after his death in 2012, he remains an extraordinary presence in Bangladeshi literature and popular culture. We celebrate his birthdays, remember his death anniversaries, revisit his stories, and continue to introduce younger readers to his work. But somewhere in this enormous affection, we have also developed a reluctance to confront the more uncomfortable aspects of his legacy. Humayun Ahmed was an influential storyteller, but he was also a man whose writing, personal decisions, and public reputation existed within the patriarchal structures of Bangladeshi society. Our admiration for him should not make those structures invisible.

I grew up reading Humayun Ahmed. His books were among the reasons I wanted to become a writer. I loved the familiarity of his language, his humour, his strange and memorable people, and the way he could turn an ordinary afternoon into an entire story. For many of us, reading Humayun Ahmed was not simply a literary experience; it was part of growing up. Perhaps that is why criticizing him can feel almost like questioning a childhood memory. Yet the books we loved when we were younger do not remain unchanged simply because our understanding of the world changes. Returning to his writing with a feminist consciousness, I find myself increasingly troubled by the gendered expectations, romantic ideals, and unequal relationships that his stories sometimes made appealing. I am also troubled by how easily his immense cultural authority has allowed those contradictions to remain secondary to the celebration of his genius.

Ahmed’s influence was not limited to literature. Beginning with Nondito Noroke in 1972, he became a prolific novelist, playwright, television writer, and filmmaker. He reached audiences across generations and social classes, including people who might never have considered themselves serious readers. His work shaped popular understandings of romance, marriage, family, friendship, masculinity, and everyday Bangladeshi life. This influence matters because stories do not exist independently of the social worlds in which they circulate. They draw upon familiar values, but they can also make those values attractive, acceptable, and difficult to question. When a writer becomes as influential as Humayun Ahmed, the relationships and behaviours he repeatedly presents as charming, tragic, or romantic deserve attention beyond their entertainment value.

One of the recurring pleasures of Ahmed’s fictional world is the unusual man: emotionally distant, unpredictable, sometimes irresponsible, but nevertheless fascinating. His unconventional behaviour becomes part of his appeal. Women, meanwhile, are frequently placed in relationships where patience, longing, emotional accommodation, and sacrifice carry a particular romantic significance. These are not universal features of his writing, nor are his women uniformly passive. He wrote women who challenged social expectations and confronted injustice. Yet there remains a recognizable imbalance in the romantic imagination associated with some of his most popular stories. Men’s refusal to conform can become an expression of freedom, while women’s willingness to endure uncertainty becomes a measure of love. The troubling part is how familiar these arrangements feel in a society where women are already expected to perform much of the emotional labour of relationships.

Humayun Ahmed did not invent these expectations. Bangladeshi literature, cinema, television, and popular music have long romanticized women’s sacrifices and excused men’s irresponsibility. But he was extraordinarily successful at making such relationships emotionally compelling. His humour and storytelling could soften the inequalities within them, turning behaviours that might otherwise invite criticism into signs of eccentricity, sensitivity, or romantic complexity. The problem is not that fiction must portray only healthy relationships. Literature would be terribly limited if that were the case. The problem arises when unequal relationships are repeatedly presented through a sentimental language that makes their underlying power differences easier to overlook. A man’s emotional unavailability may become mysterious, but a woman’s suffering becomes the evidence of how deeply she loves him.

His television work reveals another important dimension of this cultural influence. Kothao Keu Nei became a phenomenon through its Bangladesh Television adaptation in the early 1990s. Asaduzzaman Noor’s portrayal of Baker Bhai generated extraordinary public affection, and viewers reportedly organized demonstrations demanding that the fictional character not be executed. It remains one of the most remarkable examples of audience engagement in Bangladeshi television history. Yet the overwhelming public fascination with Baker Bhai also obscured other important aspects of the story. In a 2022 feminist study, Naznin Jahan examined how Kothao Keu Nei addresses the struggles of Muna and other women living within patriarchal social arrangements, even as the public reception became dominated by its male character. The contrast is revealing. Ahmed’s storytelling could expose women’s oppression, but audiences were not necessarily most interested in remembering that oppression. The charismatic man became the centre of the cultural memory.

This relationship between the writer and his audience deserves particular attention. Humayun Ahmed’s popularity among women was enormous, and many women continue to cherish his books and television dramas. There is nothing inherently contradictory about women enjoying literature that contains patriarchal assumptions. Readers can appreciate a story without accepting every value represented within it. Nevertheless, the widespread affection for his romantic imagination also tells us something about how patriarchy operates through culture. It is not sustained only by men explicitly demanding obedience or sacrifice. It also survives through the stories that teach us what love should look like, which behaviours deserve forgiveness, and whose emotional suffering is supposed to be beautiful. Women can recognize injustice in their own lives while finding similar arrangements moving or romantic in fiction. That contradiction is not a failure of individual women readers; it is part of the cultural environment in which all of us learn to understand relationships.

Questions of gender and sexuality in Ahmed’s work are also more complicated than his reputation as a writer of heterosexual middle-class life might suggest. His final film, Ghetuputra Komola (2012), provides a particularly important example. Set around the historical ghetu performance tradition, the film follows a young boy who performs in feminine clothing and becomes vulnerable to sexual exploitation by a powerful zamindar. Ahmed drew attention to a history in which young performers could be subjected to abuse by influential men, and the film exposes the devastating consequences of that power. It would therefore be inaccurate to claim that Ahmed simply ignored gender nonconformity or never challenged patriarchal violence. At the same time, the film invites questions about the ways femininity, gender ambiguity, male desire, and sexual exploitation become associated within its narrative.

The distinction between gender nonconformity and sexual violence is particularly important here. A boy wearing feminine clothing is not automatically queer or transgender, just as the sexual abuse of a child by an adult man cannot be understood as an ordinary same-sex relationship. The violence in Ghetuputra Komola is inseparable from the zamindar’s power over a vulnerable child. Ahmed’s film makes that exploitation visible, and its treatment of gender also exposes the social hostility directed at someone who does not conform to conventional masculine expectations. Yet the fact that gender difference becomes most visible through suffering raises its own questions about representation. When people who appear outside conventional gender norms enter popular narratives primarily through humiliation, ridicule, vulnerability, or tragedy, audiences may learn to pity them without necessarily recognizing their autonomy or humanity beyond those circumstances. This tension deserves attention without dismissing the film’s criticism of sexual exploitation.

There is a broader issue here concerning the humour and social familiarity that made Ahmed’s writing so accessible. His stories often drew upon the assumptions, prejudices, and everyday language of the society around him. Such material can be used to criticize social attitudes, but it can also reproduce them for amusement. Representations of people whose gender expression or behaviour falls outside conventional expectations therefore need to be considered in terms of how they are positioned within the story: whether the audience is invited to understand them, laugh at them, fear them, or simply regard them as unusual. Ahmed’s work was not politically uniform, and Ghetuputra Komola demonstrates that he could recognize violence arising from gendered power. But recognizing violence in one context does not automatically mean that a writer’s broader treatment of gender and sexuality is free from prejudice or contradiction.

Those contradictions become especially difficult to ignore when we consider Ahmed’s personal life. He married Gultekin Khan in the 1970s, and they had four surviving children together. Their marriage ended in divorce in 2003, and Ahmed subsequently married actress and singer Meher Afroz Shaon in 2005. The circumstances surrounding the breakdown of his first marriage generated considerable public controversy, including allegations and competing accounts of the relationship’s history. Some claims have been disputed, and it would be irresponsible to present speculation as established fact. But the documented sequence of events remains relevant to understanding the public life of a man whose writing was so closely associated with love, relationships, and emotional sensitivity.

Divorce and remarriage are not inherently patriarchal acts. A feminist criticism cannot condemn someone simply for leaving a marriage, particularly when women themselves continue to face social punishment for exercising that freedom. But personal freedom does not eliminate responsibility toward others, and a celebrated man’s right to make intimate decisions should not become an excuse to avoid examining the power surrounding those decisions. Ahmed’s public identity was built upon extraordinary literary prestige, professional recognition, and a devoted audience. The women connected to his life did not occupy the same position within that public narrative. While his personal history became another chapter in the biography of a celebrated writer, their lives were repeatedly discussed through their relationships with him.

Gultekin Khan’s own writing offers a revealing perspective on how women’s creative lives can disappear behind the accomplishments of famous husbands. In an interview with Prothom Alo, she described taking a long break from writing after her marriage to Ahmed. She returned to poetry years later, and her daughters encouraged her to publish her work after rediscovering an old notebook of poems. Her account does not establish that Ahmed prevented her from writing, nor should her experience be reduced to an accusation against him. But it does reveal an important imbalance in the histories we choose to celebrate. While Ahmed’s literary career became a national story, Gultekin’s creative journey remained comparatively obscure, and even her later achievements were frequently introduced through her identity as his former wife. Her life, like that of any woman, deserves to be understood beyond the marriage that made her publicly recognizable.

The treatment of Meher Afroz Shaon reveals a different manifestation of the same problem. Public discussions of Ahmed’s second marriage frequently focused on Shaon’s perceived responsibility for the breakdown of his first relationship. She became the subject of intense judgment, often through the familiar language used to condemn women accused of disrupting marriages. Such narratives can make a woman the principal villain while leaving the man’s agency comparatively unexamined. Criticizing Ahmed should not require reproducing that misogyny. Shaon is an artist and a public figure in her own right, and Gultekin is more than the former wife of a famous writer. Neither woman should be reduced to a convenient symbol through which society expresses its approval or disapproval of Ahmed’s personal decisions.

An especially revealing contemporary response appeared in The Daily Star in July 2005, when a reader defended Ahmed against criticism of his marriage to Shaon. The letter argued that his contribution to society lay in his writing and that his marriage was a private matter for which he should not be blamed. The letter was one person’s opinion, not evidence of what all his admirers believed. But it captures a familiar response to criticism of celebrated men: their professional accomplishments are invoked as though those achievements should settle questions about their personal lives. It also shows that the debate over Ahmed’s marriage was not invented retrospectively. People were already arguing about the relationship between his literary reputation, his private choices, and his public responsibility while he was alive.

There is a selective logic in the demand to separate the artist from the art. Ahmed’s admirers have often praised his sensitivity, his understanding of human relationships, and his ability to portray love and suffering with unusual emotional depth. His personality and worldview become part of the explanation for his literary greatness. Yet when uncomfortable questions emerge about his relationships or the patriarchal assumptions within his writing, those same connections are suddenly declared irrelevant. Fiction is not autobiography, and it would be absurd to treat every character as a reflection of Ahmed’s private beliefs. But an author’s public reputation is also shaped by the values audiences associate with their work. We cannot celebrate his insight into human relationships as evidence of exceptional wisdom while insisting that his own relationship to gender and power should remain entirely outside critical discussion.

The larger problem is the extraordinary generosity that Bangladeshi society extends to its celebrated men. Their personal contradictions can be understood as complexity, their mistakes as unfortunate episodes, and their achievements as sufficient reasons to preserve their reputations. Women are rarely granted the same freedom from judgment. Their marriages, divorces, relationships, appearances, and perceived failures are routinely examined as matters of public morality, often with little consideration for their accomplishments or autonomy. Ahmed’s personal history does not explain this inequality by itself, but the reception of that history offers a recognizable example of how cultural prestige shapes accountability. The celebrated man’s achievements remain central, while the women connected to him become subjects of gossip, sympathy, or condemnation.

What makes this especially difficult to confront is that Humayun Ahmed was genuinely important to Bangladeshi cultural life. His writing made literature accessible to enormous numbers of people, and his television dramas and films became shared cultural experiences. His work could be humorous, compassionate, socially observant, and critical of injustice. It could also reproduce familiar inequalities, rely upon conventional gender expectations, or present relationships through a romantic imagination that deserves questioning. These qualities are not mutually exclusive. A writer does not have to be consistently progressive or consistently reactionary for their work to carry political consequences. Indeed, the contradictions are part of what makes Ahmed worth examining rather than merely praising or condemning.

I find myself returning to the fact that I once read Humayun Ahmed without noticing many of the things that now trouble me. That earlier affection was genuine, and I do not feel compelled to deny it. But I also refuse to treat the writer who influenced my childhood as someone whose legacy must remain untouched by the political understanding I have developed since then. We change as readers, and the meanings of the stories we grew up with change alongside us. The ability to revisit a beloved writer critically should be understood as part of taking literature seriously, not as an act of disrespect toward it.

Humayun Ahmed was not required to be a feminist, and criticizing his work does not depend upon establishing that he was personally hostile to women or queer people. The more substantial criticism concerns the gendered values his stories sometimes made appealing, the limits and contradictions of his representations, the unequal power surrounding his public life, and the extraordinary cultural protection afforded to him as a celebrated man. His work contains both challenges to patriarchal violence and representations that invite feminist criticism. His personal history contains documented decisions and public controversies that deserve examination without sensationalism. None of this erases his literary accomplishments, but neither should those accomplishments erase everything else.

Bangladesh will continue to read Humayun Ahmed, and there is no reason it should not. His books and television dramas are part of our cultural history. But a literary legacy is not something we preserve responsibly by refusing to question it. The affection we feel for a writer should not determine the limits of what we are willing to say about his work or his public life. Humayun Ahmed helped generations of Bangladeshis imagine love, family, masculinity, and everyday existence. Some of those imaginings deserve admiration; others deserve criticism. If we continue to celebrate him without confronting that difference, we are not simply protecting the memory of a beloved writer. We are also protecting some of the patriarchal assumptions that made his world, and ours, so familiar.